‘Madden’ review: David O. Russell fumbles glib biopic of iconic NFL coach-commentator John Madden | Reviews

HomeReviews

‘Madden’ review: David O. Russell fumbles glib biopic of iconic NFL coach-commentator John Madden | Reviews

Dir: David O. Russell. US. 2026. 109mins Aiming to be a rambunctious comedic portrait of famed NFL coach John Madden (who died in 2021, aged 85)

Reza Rahadian’s ‘On Your Lap’ leads Busan Vision Awards with four prizes
Cannes Marche du Film expands innovation-centred programming initiatives
Meryl Streep on “Beef” With Goldie Hawn, Robert Redford Love Scenes, and What Her Grandchildren Call Her

Dir: David O. Russell. US. 2026. 109mins

Aiming to be a rambunctious comedic portrait of famed NFL coach John Madden (who died in 2021, aged 85), David O. Russell’s biopic is disappointingly shallow and uninquisitive. Nicolas Cage plays the title role with a cartoonishness that fails to capture this beloved sports figure’s outsized personality and boyish charm. And although the film covers fertile terrain — including Madden’s life after coaching as a popular television football commentator and, later, the inspiration for a lucrative videogame franchise — Russell’s glib approach quickly irritates as there’s nothing beneath the superficial flashiness.

Disappointingly shallow and uninquisitive

Madden opens in US theatres on November 18, which is the same date the picture lands on Amazon Prime  in the US, UK and other territories. Football fans could be intrigued — especially as NFL season is currently in full swing — and Cage is joined by a starry supporting cast that includes regular Russell collaborator Christian Bale. Yet Russell no longer enjoys the acclaim that accompanied his string of hits from the early 2010s: The Fighter, Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle. Negative reviews may steer audiences away, although some viewers may decide to give Madden a cursory look at home over the holidays.

Spanning the 1970s through to the 1990s, the film follows coach John Madden (Cage) as he leads the Oakland Raiders to their first Super Bowl championship in 1977. Supported by shamelessly self-promotional Raiders owner Al Davis (Bale), Madden is a strategic mastermind dedicated to winning, despite his long-suffering wife Virginia’s (Kathryn Hahn) laments that he ignores her and their two growing sons. With health concerns mounting for the overweight Madden, he decides to retire from coaching, stepping into the broadcast booth to deliver colourful commentary. Eventually, he will be approached by Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney), the founder of the videogame company Electronic Arts, who wants to develop a game based on Madden’s novel playcalling.

Russell’s first film since the critical and commercial 2022 misfire Amsterdam adopts an irreverent tone, gleefully depicting Madden’s 1970s NFL career as a hedonistic, irresponsible time in which the players smoked cigarettes and displayed as little professionalism as possible. Boasting numerous obvious rock-song needledrops, Madden invites the viewer to relish the period nostalgia — in particular, the outrageous clothes and terribly dated hairstyles. This untamed milieu is ruled by the exuberant Madden, who, along with his best friend Davis, injected an edginess into the sport. These iconoclastic characters — symbols of a bygone NFL before the league became corporate and buttoned-down — are accentuated by Cage’s noticeable prosthetics and Bale’s slicked-back hair and omnipresent sunglasses.

Initially, the film promises to hark back to American Hustle, another story inspired by actual events that played up the participants’ most extreme qualities. But the screenplay (written by Russell and Cambron Clark) covers Madden’s career highlights in such flat fashion that it strips these moments of any dramatic or comedic spark. Madden’s jump to television — where he spent years working alongside Pat Summerall (Joel Murray), becoming the NFL’s signature broadcasters — is strikingly unmemorable. And once Madden focuses on his embattled relationship with Virginia, the couple’s fights have a grating caricaturishness that makes it impossible to muster any concern for their marriage. (Hahn, a gifted comic, strains to give her character’s unfunny lines a smidge of humour.)

Cage’s amped-up performances can be galvanizing when he connects to something true in the oddballs he portrays. But while the hair and makeup team assist him resemble the portly Madden, the actor seems not to have any discernible take on a man who loved football more than anything else. Neither Cage nor the filmmakers lend insights into Madden’s much-vaunted coaching prowess, and even his unique quirks — such as his paralysing fear of flying — have little heft. Madden’s later feud with Davis, who never forgave him for leaving coaching, also underwhelms. Bale brings the right cocky attitude to his portrayal of the Raiders owner, but he too lacks any substantive grasp of what made his real-life counterpart such an appealing rascal.

Madden’s most unrewarding passages come near the end, when Russell recounts how the videogame John Madden Football — later known as Madden NFL — was created, despite Madden’s utter disinterest in videogames. Playing the ambitious, nerdy Hawkins, stand-up comedian Mulaney struggles to bring the thinly-drawn character to life. And the detailing of the game’s gradual technological improvements (better graphics, more realistic game play) possess – much like the film itself – little pizzazz.

Production companies: Escape Artists, ShowKat, Dreamcrew Entertainment, Corazon Camera

Worldwide distribution: Prime Video

Producers: Todd Black, Jason Blumenthal, Steve Tisch, Jonathan Shukat, David O. Russell, Matthew Budman, Colin Wilson

Screenplay: David O. Russell and Cambron Clark

Cinematography: Robert Richardson

Production design: David J. Bomba, Sean Ryan Jennings

Editing: Jon Poll, Alan Baumgarten, Mike Azevedo

Music: Marcelo Zarvos

Main cast: Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, John Mulaney, Snoop Dogg, Shane Gillis