‘Memories Of Lightning’ review: IDFA’s elusive, experimental Envision winner turns the true crime genre on its head | Reviews

HomeReviews

‘Memories Of Lightning’ review: IDFA’s elusive, experimental Envision winner turns the true crime genre on its head | Reviews

Dir: Riccardo Giacconi. France/Italy. 2026. 73mins Memories of Lightning appears to be about the murder of a 14-year-old girl in a rural Italian

Tessa Thompson Stokes Chaos, Lust, And Revenge
California governor proposes $1bn film and TV tax credit | News
Jane Fonda relaunches Committee For The First Amendment; hundreds from Hollywood show support

Dir: Riccardo Giacconi. France/Italy. 2026. 73mins

Memories of Lightning appears to be about the murder of a 14-year-old girl in a rural Italian village in the early 1980s. It presents itself as a making-of documentary that follows a radio journalist who is investigating not only the killing, but the way it has been forgotten, brushed under the carpet, suffocated by collective omertà. What gives this material added impact is the fact that the victim was the journalist’s aunt, who died 10 years before she was born.

A kind of ghost story, one that haunts not just the narrative but the fabric of the film

There are signs, however, that something else is going on here. This is a film of slippery mismatches between picture and soundtrack. We never see the newspaper headlines that Sibilla, the journalist in question, recounts having seen on microfiche at a local library. When she mentions a photo of her aunt taken just before the crime, the screen goes black and we hear only her voice describing the photo. Another of Sibilla’s voice-overs accompanies her visit to the now-abandoned ‘blue house’ where needy Gianna used to live, with its ‘ground-floor grocery store’. Except the house we see her standing in front of isn’t blue, and there’s no obvious former shop downstairs.

Riccardo Giaccone is not fresh to such audiovisual experiments. His 2023 film Red Giants played swift and loose with the audience’s need to believe in the story they’re being told. The success of Memories of Lightning, which premiered in Venice, will depend entirely on its ability to find sophisticated cinemagoers who are more intrigued by Giaccone’s cinematic sleight of hand, and the questions it raises, than they are irritated by the ripping up of the audience’s unspoken contract with the filmmaker. Poised between arthouse cinema and art installation, the film’s IDFA Envision win could lead to further festival berths and perhaps assist attract a wider audience.

An actor reads out the confession of a murderer. He’s visibly upset by the words that radio journalist Sibilla has asked him to voice – words that describe the killing of a youthful girl that took place on Midsummer’s Day in 1982. Yet Sibilla Scinti Roger is herself an actress. She is also credited here as co-screenwriter, alongside director Giacconi. Has she ever worked as a radio journalist? Curious viewers who turn to the Internaet will find no evidence of this. The same goes for the murder she’s investigating.

We watch, and listen, as Sibilla interviews some of the inhabitants of the village in the Italian region of Le Marche, where the crime supposedly took place. Among them are the mayor, a local doctor, a friend of Sibilla’s mother – Gianna’s sister. It soon becomes clear that the family moved away soon after Gianna’s death. Sibilla was born elsewhere, and her return is tentative and tense.

Older locals are reluctant to rake up the past. Those who were not yet born in 1982 claim to know nothing of the crime. After all, so much has been erased since then. We hear of an earthquake, a village that was flooded to make an artificial lake, a theatre that burned down. After one devastating interview, the radio journalist and her guest sit in silence to capture the room tone. In another, we see but can’t hear her interviewee because, we are told, Sibilla forgot to press the record button. But suddenly her words emerge – dubbed by Sibilla.

Memories of Lightning is, we gradually realise, a kind of ghost story, one that haunts not just the narrative but the fabric of the film. This is a documentary – or a fictional narrative? – with its inner machinery showing on the outside, where we discover it’s malfunctioning, not joined up. To recalibrate our expectations and ask ourselves what the film is, once it has stopped being the record of a Serial-style true crime podcast, is an effort not every audience member will be inclined to make. But there’s plenty of scope in this dense, cerebral cinematic tesseract for those who accept the challenge.

Production companies: La Bete, Botafuego

International sales: La Bete fabrizio@labete.fr

Producers: Fabrizio Polpettini. Riccardo Giacconi

Screenplay: Riccardo Giacconi,. Sibilla Scinti Roger

Cinematography: Ahmad Al-Zu’bi, Giulia Marzin

Editing: Riccardo Giacconi, Gabriel Gonzalez