Dir. Janno Jürgens. Estonia. 2026. 95mins Two sisters, living in the same minuscule Estonian community and working as teachers at the same local
Dir. Janno Jürgens. Estonia. 2026. 95mins
Two sisters, living in the same minuscule Estonian community and working as teachers at the same local school, have drifted so far apart that they barely speak or even look at each other. A tragedy – the accidental death of one of their sons – prompts a reset. For a while, they are inseparable. But the tensions from the past re-emerge, now bolstered by more recent guilt and secrets. Janno Jürgens’s second feature makes striking employ of the enigmatic mystery of the Estonian woods and forests but, as a study of a knotty relationship, it can feel rather contrived and ponderous handed.
The tension that the film creates doesn’t always feel fully earned
Jürgens returns to Tallinn’s competition with his sophomore feature, which screens in the festival’s main competition. His debut, Rain, premiered in the Baltic strand of the 2020 edition of the festival, and went on to pick up other minor festival prizes. No Me Without You is a strikingly designed work which employs the visual language of a psychological thriller, but the tension that the film creates doesn’t always feel fully earned. This is perhaps because, despite flashbacks, we don’t know much about the nature of a conflict which has its roots in the two women’s childhood. The intense, abrasive performances from both lead actresses may not be enough to extend the film’s impact far beyond the festival circuit.
Eva Koldits plays Katrin, the older of the two sisters. Dark-haired, grave and reserved, she enjoys a comfortably affluent life in her glass-fronted, plant-filled modernist home with husband Raivo (Andres Mähar), who loves to cook and is emotionally present in the lives of Katrin and the daughter that they share. Blonde, outgoing Mari (Mari Abel) is a single mother; her home is more bohemian and cluttered, less ostentatiously moneyed but pretty in its own eccentric way.
It is Mari’s son who is hit by a car and killed, walking home from school while his mother celebrates her birthday with colleagues, And it is Katrin, who skips her estranged sister’s birthday drinks, who may have been the one to hit him. Although she got out of the car following the sound of a minor impact and found nothing when she searched the roadside and woodland area, Katrin’s certainty that she killed the boy grows along with the sickening sense of guilt and personal debt.
Katrin’s determination to make amends brings her to Mari’s door with bags full of food. She quietly takes over the running of the home, wrangling a neglected vacuum cleaner and mowing the lawn. The physical intimacy that they shared as children (shown in a flashback of two fleet, barefoot girls wrestling in the Estonian swamplands) gradually returns, and Mari permits herself to lean on her sister once more. But the flashback also shows how easily the physical intimacy between the sisters can tip over into violence and savagery. And for some reason, which is never entirely made clear, neither seem to have grown out of this behaviour pattern. Meanwhile, a detective, who seems more like a symbolic narrative device than an original character, loiters on the periphery of the story, asking loaded questions.
Erik Põllumaa’s camera captures the lush, verdant forested backdrop, showing us a place which is wild, earthy and full of semi-submerged threats. The score – plenty of brooding, ominous droning – does a lot of ponderous lifting in a picture which takes a pointed turn into family dysfunction in the third act. But for all the cruelty that the women are prepared to display to each other, the complicated barbed-wire bonds of their love for each other only get tighter as the story unfolds.
Production company: Filmivabrik
International sales: Loco Films international@loco-films.com
Producer: Marju Lepp
Screenplay: Janno Jürgens, Anti Naulainen
Cinematography: Erik Põllumaa
Production design: Matis Mäesalu
Editing: Andres Hallik
Music: Maarja Nuut
Main cast: Eva Koldits, Mari Abel, Andres Mähar, Katariina Unt
